skip to main content
Green Section RecordDecember 01, 2019
Volume 57, Issue 23
Green Section RecordDecember 01, 2019
Volume 57, Issue 23

Hormonal Responses—Are They Helping Or Hurting Your Greens?

Products that contain hormones must be used appropriately to maximize their positive effects.

December 06, 2019
Steve Kammerer, Ph.D., regional director, Southeast RegionAdam Moeller, director, Green Section Education
Ultradwarf bermudagrass putting greens can experience severe damage from prolonged freezing temperatures. Elevation of abscisic acid levels helps turfgrass withstand freezing conditions.

Turf stress on putting greens is inevitable, and when it happens our first inclination is to look for diseases or signs of environmental stress. When these issues aren’t the problem, we’re often left scratching our head. Understandably, attributing turf problems to plant hormones is usually not the first thing that comes to mind.

Various plant protectants, plant growth regulators and biostimulants either contain hormones or elicit hormone responses. While these products can be valuable tools to help keep your turf performing well, there are situations where they could create problems through hormone responses. Before we discuss how to avoid unexpected issues, let’s review how turf stress and hormones are related.

Turf Stress and Hormones

Hormone production or suppression within the plant can be triggered by numerous environmental stresses such as extreme heat, cold, drought and high salt concentrations. When stress develops, various hormones inside the plant elicit a natural self-defense mechanism to help the turf survive. Biological signals from disease-causing pathogens and insects can also cause hormone responses.

Hormone response is self-regulated by the plant and is usually an afterthought for turf managers since we can’t see inside plants and hormone responses are complex. But, understanding the basic hormonal responses is critical to avoiding unintentional stress.

Five of the major plant hormones critical to turf health and performance include auxin, cytokinin, ethylene, abscisic acid and gibberellic acid. Other hormones have been discovered and researched, but cytokinin, gibberellic acid and abscisic acid arguably have the most significant impact on turf health, so a brief description of their function is included below (Yamaguchi, et. al., 2010):

Cytokinin: Depending on concentrations inside the plant, this hormone regulates the rate of cell division, gas exchange through stomatal openings and root development. It is the primary hormone that governs the rate of growth.  

Gibberellic acid (GA): This is a growth stimulator that is important in cell growth and elongation, and breaking dormancy. High or increased gibberellic acid levels from product applications during periods where freezing temperatures are likely can affect the tolerance of turfgrass to cold and freezing temperatures. Gibberellic acid also promotes seed germination and seedling development. Suppressing gibberellic acid levels can cause the turf to become compact or stunted.  

Abscisic acid (ABA): This hormone is a growth inhibitor, commonly referred to as the stress hormone. It enables the plant physiology for self-defense. It prolongs dormancy, increases water conservation via stomatal closure and inhibits cell division, elongation and growth. 

Heat stress on creeping bentgrass leads to hormone-driven stomatal closure to combat wilting. This can result in oxidative stress and, under prolonged conditions, turfgrass thinning and loss.

Hormone levels inside the plant constantly fluctuate to meet the needs of the turf. Different hormones and their concentrations can either be synergistic or antagonistic to each other. For instance, cytokinin can be antagonistic to gibberellic acid and abscisic acid while abscisic acid can be antagonistic to gibberellic acid. Gibberellic acid can work in synergy with auxin hormones at specific concentrations, leading to cell elongation and division, but these hormones can also stimulate ethylene production, which can inhibit root elongation. As mentioned earlier, hormone responses are complex so it’s understandable why there can be confusion.

One of the most common examples of manipulating hormone responses inside the plant is observed when trinexapac-ethyl is applied to turf that is shaded. Trinexapac-ethyl increases cytokinin production, which antagonizes the effects of gibberellic acid. Research has shown that trinexapac-ethyl, through suppression of gibberellic acid, can increase shade tolerance of bermudagrass putting greens (Bunnell, McCarty & Bridges, 2005 and Baldwin, et. al., 2009). There are other benefits to applying trinexapac-ethyl to putting greens beyond improved shade tolerance, but these are rate and timing specific. Nonetheless, the manipulation of hormone response inside the plant with trinexapac-ethyl is a good reminder of how some products work. 

Products That May Cause Hormone Responses

Various plant protectants, plant growth regulators, plant defense stimulators and biostimulants may cause hormone responses. The hormonal impacts of each of these product types are discussed below. 

Plant Protectants

Protecting turf from diseases and insects with fungicides or insecticides is a necessity at most golf courses. These applications are primarily intended for managing pests. However, research indicates that some products can provide additional plant health benefits via hormonal responses. For instance, strobilurin fungicides can stimulate plant hormone responses that result in decreased respiration (Debona et. al., 2016). Decreased respiration will likely result in reduced carbohydrate consumption, which should result in more energy conserved for turf growth.

With phosphonate fungicides and fertilizers, salicylic acid levels increase the host-defense system of the plant, similar to abscisic acid but through a different physiological pathway (Groves, Howard, Hardy and Burgess, 2014). Ironically, though their physiological responses are similar in plants, salicylic acid and absicisic acid can be antagonistic, causing a loss in host defense to pathogens (Jiang, Chang-Jie, et. al., 2010). As mentioned before, hormone responses are complex.

The same variety of bermudagrass can demonstrate different growth characteristics based on sunlight duration and intensity. Notice the difference between grass growing with greater sunlight compared to shade.

 

Any enhanced plant health response from plant protectants in addition to pest control is an added benefit. However, there are inherent risks associated with applying these products without pest pressure. One obvious issue is that each application is costly, and it may be difficult to determine if the small increases in plant health are cost effective. More importantly, increasing the usage of fungicides that provide plant health benefits increases the likelihood of disease resistance without appropriate rotation of active ingredients.

In some cases, the desired plant health response from a specific product depends on the application rate or timing (Martins, et. al., 2012). If an application is made while turf is under stress, the product could actually increase turf stress. For example, some strobilurin fungicides, like pyraclostrobin, are marketed as increasing summer stress tolerance as a result of increased abscisic acid levels inside the plant. However, when researchers applied strobilurin fungicides to creeping bentgrass they could not detect specific physiological benefits independent of disease control (Benelli, 2013 and Grossmann, Kwiatkowski & Caspar 1999).

Plant Growth Regulators

Plant growth regulators have been commonly used for many years. Trinexapac-ethyl and prohexadione-calcium reduce growth by inhibiting the plant hormone gibberellic acid. These Class A growth regulators inhibit gibberellic acid late in the synthesis of this hormone, resulting in greater efficiency in reducing excessive leaf growth and clippings. Class B growth regulators, like flurprimidol and paclobutrazol, inhibit synthesis of gibberellic acid as well, but earlier in its formation and with longer-lasting effects beyond just leaf growth. Class B growth regulators are also soil-active, with increased uptake potential with water through roots. Ethephon enhances plant maturation, leading to increased ethylene levels in plants that increase fruit ripening. On Poa annua greens, ethephon is commonly applied to help suppress seedheads.

Plant Defense Stimulators

Plant defense stimulators – e.g., acibenzolar – are different than plant growth regulators in that their activity is not constrained to effects on growth. They either contain hormones, directly activate hormones or are hormone mimics that are physiological effectors of turf. These may or may not affect growth or plant function. Examples of these are salicylic acid and acibenzolar. Acibenzolar is marketed as a plant activator, with claims of increasing tolerance to heat and drought (Jesperen, Jingjin, and Bingru 2017). These claims are attributed to acibenzolar sold as a premix in combination with a fungicide, but the activity of acibenzolar alone can be difficult to ascertain. There are also several companies marketing salicylic acid in combination with amino acids for reducing plant stress or assisting in nutrient uptake – e.g., Green-T Impulse®. Amino acids will be discussed in more detail below.

Biostimulants

Biostimulants encompass a huge array of different products that are becoming increasingly marketed and used in golf turf management. These products are often marketed as soil amendments or added into traditional plant protectants or fertilizer products. By definition, a biostimulant is something that temporarily increases the activity of some physiological plant process. Researchers have found various plant health benefits from biostimulants, although these are sometimes difficult to document in the field. The interactions between biostimulants, plant hormones and turf response is not well researched.

Seaweed extracts and humic acids appear to be the most widely used biostimulants in the golf turf market. Both contain hormones and amino acids that exhibit cytokinin and auxin hormone responses. These products are likely to be most beneficial when applied prior to stresses caused by drought, heat, salinity and potentially other issues that adversely impact turf health.

Molasses extract from sugar is sold in the golf turf market as a carbon source of amino acids. There are a multitude of claimed benefits associated with molasses applications, such as increasing populations of beneficial organisms like bacteria or fungi. In theory, if beneficial nonpathogenic bacteria or fungi populations are increased in the soil, there would be lower populations of pathogenic fungi in comparison. Molasses is also known to contain amino acids that may elicit a hormonal response, but research is inconclusive in this area. As a result, the specific hormone response is unknown.

Lastly, there are many bacteria and fungi that produce compounds that can either produce or elicit a hormonal response in plants. Hormones within plants – such as gibberellic acid, auxin, cytokinin and ethylene – can be directly or indirectly triggered by these microorganisms. In the case of plant-growth-promoting Rhizobacteria, root-inhabiting bacteria can produce hormones, metabolize them or directly affect a plants’ hormone production. Mycorhizal fungi are also known to produce hormones such as gibberellic acid and cytokinins (Barea and Azcòn-Aguilar, 1981).  These are being commercialized and used to reduce reliance on synthetic fertilizers and pesticides in agriculture.

Water with elevated salt levels can impart a growth-regulating effect on turfgrass. Ultradwarf bermudagrass irrigated with water containing 7,500 ppm of salt (back row) showed signs of reduced growth after three days of irrigation.

 

Temperature Extremes and Hormones

Applying products that may contain gibberellic acid or stimulate gibberellic acid production during temperature extremes is discouraged. During a freeze period or stretch of hot weather, applying a product that increases gibberellic acid would be antagonistic to the natural hormone defense response from abscisic acid. When temperatures drop to freezing conditions over several days, abscisic acid levels increase within turf roots in both warm- and cool-season turf species. This acclimation reduces the potential for winter injury. Encouraging dormant turf, or turf under stress from hot temperatures, to grow by applying a product designed to increase gibberellic acid levels could lead to additional stress and possible turf loss.

Product Selection

Putting greens are inherently under stress on a regular basis, and natural hormones inside the plant help the turf withstand this stress. At times, the turf cannot withstand the multitude of stresses with natural hormones alone. Superintendents utilize plant protectants, plant growth regulators, and to a lesser extent biostimulants, to keep putting green turf healthy and playing well despite these stresses. It gets incredibly complicated when applying products that contain hormones which could inadvertently create additional stress. While the claims can be broad, it cannot always be known how a product performs on your golf course unless it is applied alone.

Unlike traditional products used for controlling pests, the benefits of products that claim to increase plant health as a result of hormone responses are more difficult to ascertain. For example, a superintendent cannot assess an increase in photosynthesis without having access to expensive equipment and a well-equipped laboratory.

The best way to understand if hormones or hormone mimics are in a product is to ask the distributer and manufacturer. Without knowing the contents of a product, the hormone responses and plant health benefits can be unpredictable. A good analogy is our power grid. If every electrical device is turned on at the same time, there won’t be enough power to run everything. The same is true with hormones inside turf plants. If all the hormones inside the plant are turned on by using products containing hormones or hormone mimics, there will likely be either no response or a negative response.

Prior to purchasing a new product, seek out statistically analyzed data regarding the claimed benefits, not just side-by-side pictures. The best way to assess the performance of a product is by applying it alone over two to three months in a test area. Use a check plot to better understand the benefits or stresses from the product. If positive results are observed, the next step is to look at how this product performs in conjunction with other commonly applied products that produce desirable responses.

Conclusion

The number of products available to help keep putting greens healthy and playing well can be overwhelming. Manufacturers test products for years in a variety of conditions to ensure that when used properly they will not have any harmful effects on the turf, the environment, applicators or anyone that comes in contact with them. The unintended side effects that are possible when products containing hormones, or eliciting a hormonal response, are applied to turf under stress are difficult to predict. When developing a spray program for putting greens, it is best to keep the plan simple. Utilizing multiple plant growth regulators and biostimulants with additional products will result in unpredictable results and could add stress to the turf. There is value in applying products that contain hormones, but they must be used appropriately to maximize their positive effects.  

 

References

Baldwin, C., Liu, H., McCarty, L. B., Luo, H and Toler, J. E. 2009. Nitrogen and Plant Growth Regulator Influence on ‘Champion’ Bermudagrass Putting Green under Reduced Sunlight. Agronomy Journal. 101(1): 75-81.

Barea, J., and Azcòn-Aguilar, C. 1981. Production of Plant Growth-Regulating Substances by the Vesicular-Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungus Glomus mosseae. Appl. and Environ. Microbiology. 43: 810-813.

Benelli, Jesse J. 2013. Non-target effects of strobilurin fungicide applications on creeping bentgrass putting greens during summer stress. Master's Thesis, University of Tennessee.

Bunnell, B. T., L. B. McCarty, and W. C. Bridges. 2005. ‘TifEagle’ Bermudagrass Response to Growth Factors and Mowing Height when Grown at Various Hours of Sunlight. Crop Sci. 45: 575-581.

Debona, D., Nascimento, K., Gomes, J., Aucique-Perez, C.E., and Rodrigues, F.A. 2016. Physiological changes promoted by a strobilurin fungicide in the rice - Bipolaris oryzae interaction. Pesticide Biochemisty and Physiology. 130: 8-16.

Groves, E., Howard, K., Hardy, G., and Burgess, T. 2015. Role of salicylic acid in phosphite-induced protection against Oomycetes; a Phytophthora cinnamomic – Lupinus augustifolius model system. European Journal of Plant Pathology. 141: 559-569.

Grossmann, K., Kwiatkowski, J., and Caspar, G.  1999. Regulation of Phytohormone Levels, Leaf Senescence and Transpiration by the Strobilurin Kresoxim-methyl in Wheat (Triticum aestivum). Journal of Plant Physiology. 154: 805-808.

Jespersen, D., Jingjin, Y., and Bingru, H.  2017. Metabolic Effects of Acibenzolar-S-Methyl for Improving Heat or Drought Stress in Creeping Bentgrass. Frontiers in Plant Science. 8: Article 1224.

Jiang, Chang-Jie, Shimono, M., Sugano, S., Kojima, M., Yazawa, K., Yoshida, R., Inoue, H., Hayashi, N., Sakakibara, H., and Takatsuji, H.  2010.  Abscisic Acid Interacts Antagonistically with Salicylic Acid Signaling Pathway in Rice – Magnaporthe grisea Interaction. Molecular Plant – Microbe Interactions. 23(6): 791-798.

Martins, R., Martins, M., Silva, J., Pereira, M., Appezzato-da-Glória, B., and Castro, P.  2012. Thiamethoxam on the histological characteristics of sugarcane young roots.  Ciência Rural. 42: 1936-1940.

Yamaguchi, I., Cohenk, J., Culler, A., Quint, M., Slovin, J., Nakajima, M., Yamaguchi, S., Sakakibara, H., Kuroha, T., Hirai, N., Yokota, T., Ohta, H., Kobayashi, Y., Mori, H., and Sakagami., Y. 2010. Comprehensive Natural Products II – Chemistry and Biology, Plant Hormones. 4: 9-125. 

Rate This Article
Your opinion matters to us!